Compare
Smart Wine Cellar vs CellarTracker
Both keep your cellar free. Smart Wine Cellar adds a modern app, tastings with your friends and a flat $5 Pro plan that does not grow with your collection.
30-day Pro trial & forever-free plan. No credit card required.
CellarTracker has been around for more than twenty years and it shows in the best way: an enormous wine database, more than 10 million community tasting notes and unlimited free inventory. If you want to read what hundreds of other people thought of a specific bottle, nothing else comes close.
Smart Wine Cellar is built for the other half of owning wine: knowing what to open tonight, finding it in the rack, pairing it with dinner and sharing it with friends. It is designed for your phone first, and the Pro plan costs the same whether you own 50 bottles or 5,000.
Choose CellarTracker if
- You want to read community notes on almost any bottle
- You want to look up almost any wine in a huge shared database
Choose Smart Wine Cellar if
- You want an app that feels good to use on your phone
- You want wine list picks at restaurants based on your own taste
- You host tastings and want guests to vote without signing up
- You want one flat Pro price, whatever the size of your cellar
- You want to see exactly where each bottle sits in your rack
Side by side
Feature by feature
| Feature | Smart Wine Cellar | CellarTracker |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free, Pro $5/month | Free, subscriptions $40 to $500/year |
| Free plan | Yes Cellar, rack, wine list and tastings | Yes Unlimited bottles |
| Platforms | iPhone, Android and web | iPhone, Android and web |
| Drinking windows | Yes Set your own per bottle too | Yes |
| AI help that knows your cellar | Paid plan Food Matcher and restaurant picks | Paid plan CellarChat, subscribers only |
| Food pairing from bottles you own | Paid plan Only suggests bottles you own | Paid plan Through CellarChat |
| Restaurant wine list scanner | Paid plan Picks based on your own ratings | No |
| Label scanning | Yes | Yes Label photo search |
| Rack map with each bottle's spot | Yes Exact row and column | Partly Bin locations, no visual map |
| Cellar value | Paid plan Not in the free trial | Paid plan Auction-based valuation |
| Critic and community ratings | Paid plan Next to your own rating | Yes Community scores |
| Cellar temperature and humidity | Paid plan Via Home Assistant | No |
| Host tastings with guest voting | Yes Guests need no account | No |
| Import from CellarTracker | Yes Full inventory and history | Not applicable |
| Large community of tasting notes | No Built around your own notes | Yes 10M+ tasting notes |
Last checked September 2026, from CellarTracker's public website, app store listings and independent reviews.
Features we could not confirm either way are left out.
Where it is different
What you get with Smart Wine Cellar
Switching is easy
Already on CellarTracker?
Bring it all with you.
Import your full inventory and drinking history in a few minutes. No re-typing and no starting from an empty cellar.
Import my cellarQuestions
Good to know
Is Smart Wine Cellar a good CellarTracker alternative?
Yes, if you want a modern app built around your own cellar. Smart Wine Cellar covers inventory, drinking windows and a visual rack map, and adds hosted tastings, food pairing from bottles you own and a restaurant wine list scanner. CellarTracker is still the place for its huge community of tasting notes.
Can I import my CellarTracker cellar?
Yes. Smart Wine Cellar imports your full CellarTracker inventory and drinking history in a few minutes, so you keep your bottles, locations and notes without typing anything again.
Is Smart Wine Cellar cheaper than CellarTracker?
Both have a free plan. CellarTracker's subscription is priced by cellar size, from $40 to $500 a year. Smart Wine Cellar Pro is $5 a month however many bottles you own, and every new account gets a 30-day Pro trial with no credit card.
Does Smart Wine Cellar have community tasting notes like CellarTracker?
Not in the same way. Smart Wine Cellar is built around your own notes and ratings, and shows critic and community ratings next to your own on each wine. If reading thousands of other people's notes matters most to you, CellarTracker is hard to beat.
More comparisons
Smart Wine Cellar vs the rest
CellarTracker is a trademark of its owner. Smart Wine Cellar is not affiliated with or endorsed by CellarTracker. Prices and features change, so check their site for the latest.